UPR Sexual Rights Database

Search & Filters

Select one or more parameters to begin your search. You may also search by keyword at any time.

UN Member State that is reviewed on its human rights record as part of the UPR process.

Categories of the types of information used during reviews

Show advanced filters
Source of Reference

Recommending State

UN Member State or Permanent Observer making sexual rights related recommendations, comments or asking questions to the State under Review.

Review Documentation

Sources of information used as the basis for a State’s review.  Includes the State’s National Report, UN Compilation Report and a Stakeholder Summary.

UN Regional Group to which State under Review belongs.

UN Regional Group to which Recommending State belongs.

This will only match recommendations where the Source of Review is a State.

Implementation notes

State responses to recommendations and issues raised in the UN Compilation and Stakeholder summary.

Displaying 43451 - 43475 of 58126 recommendations found
  • State Under Review:

    San Marino

    San Marino
    Regional group
    WEOG
    Source Of Reference:

    Spain

    Spain
    Regional group
    WEOG
    Political group
    EU
    OEI
    Issue:
    • Women's participation
    Type:
    Recommendation
    Session:
    34th Session, November 2019
    Status:
    Accepted
    Contents:
    Intensify efforts to increase the representation of women in political life, in particular in the Parliament.
    Explanation
    the San Marino legal system already contains measures to increase the representation of women in political life, such as the mandatory representation of at least 1/3 of women in electoral lists of political forces. After the last general elections, held on 8 December 2019, women participation in Parliament raised to 31.5%, compared to 26.3% of the previous legislature. In addition, one of the two Heads of State for the current six-month term and the Minister of Internal Affairs are women. With regard to public officials, women, also in managerial positions, hold most of these positions in San Marino.
  • State Under Review:

    San Marino

    San Marino
    Regional group
    WEOG
    Source Of Reference:

    Iceland

    Iceland
    Regional group
    WEOG
    Issue:
    • Abortion
    Type:
    Recommendation
    Session:
    34th Session, November 2019
    Status:
    Unclear Response
    Contents:
    Eliminate criminal sanctions against women and girls in cases of voluntary abortion and eliminate all barriers that currently hinder access to legal, affordable, and timely termination of pregnancy.
    Explanation
    Noted … we are currently not able to accept these recommendations, as the debate on the decriminalization of abortion is underway in our country, especially in the light of popular legislative initiatives having a diametrically opposed content. The parliamentary debate should take place in 2020.
  • State Under Review:

    San Marino

    San Marino
    Regional group
    WEOG
    Source Of Reference:

    France

    France
    Regional group
    WEOG
    Political group
    EU
    OIF
    Issue:
    • Rights of same-sex desiring persons
    • Transgender persons' rights
    Type:
    Recommendation
    Session:
    20th session, November 2014
    Status:
    Accepted
    Contents:
    Ensure respect for minorities, especially sexual minorities.
    Implementation
    National Report:
    Para 29) The fundamental principle of equality expressed in Art. 4 of the Declaration on the Citizens’ Rights is further applied in concrete terms in Law no. 66 of 28 April 2008 "Provisions on racial, ethnic, religious and sexual discrimination", which supplemented the provisions of the current Criminal Code. A new offence was introduced with Article 179 bis, which punishes anyone disseminating by any means ideas based on racial or ethnic superiority or hatred, or inciting someone to commit, or committing discriminatory acts on the grounds of race, ethnicity, nationality, religion or sexual orientation. This offence can be prosecuted ex officio. Article 179 bis was then amended with Law no. 57 of 6 May 2016 "Rules adjusting San Marino legal system to the provisions of the Council of Europe Convention on preventing and combating violence against women and domestic violence" by introducing the prohibition of discrimination based on gender identity.
    Para 28) … Moreover, Article 235 of the Criminal Code has been amended in relation to family maltreatment, also introducing the offence of domestic violence, and Article 179 bis of the Criminal Code has been supplemented with the prohibition to discriminate based on gender identity.
    Para 46) As already mentioned, Law no. 57/2016 introduced the prohibition of discrimination based on gender identity.
    Para 47) With Law no. 147 of 20 November 2018, San Marino has introduced a completely new and modern institution, mainly for the protection of same-sex couples, i.e. the "Law regulating civil registered partnerships", under which the legal system recognises equal dignity, rights and safeguards to civilly registered partners, both homosexual and heterosexual couples, compared to married ones. Citizens who decide to register their partnership civilly, in accordance with the aforementioned Law and its Regulation, acquire the same status as married couples in terms of residence and succession, cohabitation, mutual assistance, inheritance rights and other matters, whether the couple is of the same sex or of a different sex.
    Para 48) Sexual education programmes are carried out in schools at all levels where education is compulsory, accompanied by emotional education programmes: these two aspects are never separated from each other in view of an integrated and complex education. Moreover, in this regard, programmes are implemented concerning education on respect for others, non-violence, as well as inclusion and solidarity amongst peers. The “Curriculum of education to citizenship” has been introduced as part of the ongoing reform of San Marino school curricula. This curriculum expressly provides for knowledge of LGBT rights.

    UN Compilation:
    Para 9) While taking note of the existing legal provisions against discrimination, the Human Rights Committee was concerned that San Marino had not yet adopted comprehensive antidiscrimination legislation and that articles 90 and 179 bis of the Criminal Code relating to discrimination only referred to discrimination based on racial, ethnic, national, religious and sexual orientation grounds and not other grounds for discrimination, such as gender identity.
    Para 11) The OHCHR Regional Office for Europe noted with concern that same-sex couples did not have the right to adopt children, marry or obtain another form of legal recognition of their relationships in San Marino.

    Stakeholder Summary:
    Para 18) CHR of CoE observed that while discrimination, hate speech and hate crimes on the basis of sexual orientation had thus become criminal offences, no similar provision existed for gender identity or sex characteristics. The Commissioner also observed that there was no constitutional or other provision expressly providing for equality before the law irrespective of sexual orientation, gender identity or sex characteristics, nor specific civil or administrative law provisions explicitly prohibiting discrimination on these grounds in the field of employment, access to goods or services, or any other area.
  • State Under Review:

    San Marino

    San Marino
    Regional group
    WEOG
    Source Of Reference:

    Stakeholder Summary

    Issue:
    • International human rights instruments
    • Violence against women / gender-based violence
    • Domestic violence
    Type:
    Review Documentation
    Session:
    34th Session, November 2019
    Status:
    Reference Addressed
    Contents:
    CHR of CoE urged the authorities to ratify … the Istanbul Convention on preventing and combating violence against women and domestic violence. [Para 4]
  • State Under Review:

    San Marino

    San Marino
    Regional group
    WEOG
    Source Of Reference:

    UN Compilation

    Issue:
    • Marginalized groups of women
    • Violence against women / gender-based violence
    • Domestic violence
    Type:
    Review Documentation
    Session:
    20th session, November 2014
    Status:
    Neglected
    Contents:
    ... Protect girls and women with disabilities [from gender-based and domestic violence], and to help girls and women gain access to assistance. [Para 9]
  • State Under Review:

    San Marino

    San Marino
    Regional group
    WEOG
    Source Of Reference:

    National Report

    Issue:
    • Sexual harassment
    • Sexual exploitation / slavery
    Type:
    Review Documentation
    Session:
    7th session, February 2010
    Status:
    N/A
    Contents:
    Slavery and slave trade are prohibited by the Criminal Code, which criminalises the acts of reducing someone in slavery and trading and trafficking in slaves. Moreover, other forms of reduction in slavery are criminalised, namely kidnapping, violation of sexual freedom, sexual abuse of minors or consenting incapable persons, sexual harassment, kidnapping with the purpose of engaging in sexual acts and corruption of minors. These provisions have been further supplemented by Law No. 61 of 30 April 2002 aimed at eradicating sexual exploitation of minors. San Marino has ratified the Supplementary Convention on the abolition of slavery, slave trade and practices comparable to slavery, as well as ILO Conventions No. 29 on forced labour, No. 105 on the abolition thereof and No. 182 on the worst forms of child labour. [Para 85]
  • State Under Review:

    San Marino

    San Marino
    Regional group
    WEOG
    Source Of Reference:

    Spain

    Spain
    Regional group
    WEOG
    Political group
    EU
    OEI
    Issue:
    • Sexual exploitation / slavery
    • International human rights instruments
    Type:
    Recommendation
    Session:
    7th session, February 2010
    Status:
    Accepted
    Contents:
    To ratify OP-CRC-SC
    Implementation
    National Report:
    Para 18) On 21 July 2011, San Marino ratified the two OPs to the Convention on the Rights of the Child on the Sale of Children, Child Prostitution and Child Pornography ... The two Protocols entered into force for San Marino on 26 October 2011.
  • State Under Review:

    San Marino

    San Marino
    Regional group
    WEOG
    Source Of Reference:

    Israel

    Israel
    Regional group
    WEOG
    Issue:
    • Other
    • Rights of same-sex desiring persons
    Type:
    Recommendation
    Session:
    7th session, February 2010
    Status:
    Rejected
    Contents:
    To create and adopt all legislative and administrative measures necessary to ensure that all families, including those based on non-conventional family models, are treated equally under the law, particularly with regard to issues of residency and inheritance.
    Explanation
    The special role played by the family has always been recognised in the Republic of San Marino, since it is a fundamental and highly valuable unit of society. According to the family law presently in force, family is based on marriage, which is defined as the "union between a man and a woman, based on the free and responsible choice and on the moral and legal equality of both partners" (Art. 1 of Law no. 49 of 26 April 1986). The San Marino Welfare State provides for several social benefits and assistance measures to support also non-conventional family models. However, there are still differences between traditional family models based on marriage and other models. Therefore, the Republic of San Marino is not in a position to accept Recommendations 28/29/30.
    Implementation
    National Report:
    Para 73) San Marino continues to protect the institution of the family, understood as a union between a man and a woman which includes children born or adopted during the marriage ...

    Stakeholder Summary:
    Para 8) CoE-ECRI noted that a law amending the Criminal Code with new provisions against discrimination based on ... sexual orientation grounds had been passed ...
  • State Under Review:

    San Marino

    San Marino
    Regional group
    WEOG
    Source Of Reference:

    Tunisia

    Tunisia
    Regional group
    Africa Group
    Political group
    AU
    OIC
    AL
    OIF
    Issue:
    • Violence against women / gender-based violence
    • Domestic violence
    • Women's and / or girls' rights
    Type:
    Recommendation
    Session:
    34th Session, November 2019
    Status:
    Accepted
    Contents:
    Continue combating discrimination against women, domestic violence and gender-based violence.
  • State Under Review:

    San Marino

    San Marino
    Regional group
    WEOG
    Source Of Reference:

    Philippines

    Philippines
    Regional group
    Asia-Pacific Group
    Political group
    ASEAN
    Issue:
    • Women's participation
    Type:
    Recommendation
    Session:
    34th Session, November 2019
    Status:
    Accepted
    Contents:
    Redouble efforts in increasing the political participation of women.
    Explanation
    the San Marino legal system already contains measures to increase the representation of women in political life, such as the mandatory representation of at least 1/3 of women in electoral lists of political forces. After the last general elections, held on 8 December 2019, women participation in Parliament raised to 31.5%, compared to 26.3% of the previous legislature. In addition, one of the two Heads of State for the current six-month term and the Minister of Internal Affairs are women. With regard to public officials, women, also in managerial positions, hold most of these positions in San Marino.
  • State Under Review:

    San Marino

    San Marino
    Regional group
    WEOG
    Source Of Reference:

    Thailand

    Thailand
    Regional group
    Asia-Pacific Group
    Political group
    ASEAN
    Issue:
    • International human rights instruments
    Type:
    Recommendation
    Session:
    20th session, November 2014
    Status:
    Accepted
    Contents:
    Consider becoming a party to other related human rights instruments, such as the OP-CRC-IC.
    Explanation
    The OP-CRC-IC is currently being considered.
    Implementation
    National Report:
    Para 15) In accordance with the recommendations accepted in the second UPR round: … (c) on 27 September 2018, San Marino acceded to the OP-CRC-IC, done at New York on 19 December 2011;
  • State Under Review:

    San Marino

    San Marino
    Regional group
    WEOG
    Source Of Reference:

    UN Compilation

    Issue:
    • Abortion
    Type:
    Review Documentation
    Session:
    34th Session, November 2019
    Status:
    Reference Addressed
    Contents:
    The OHCHR Regional Office for Europe noted that abortion remained illegal under most circumstances in San Marino. In 2017, a popular initiative to legalize abortion had triggered strong divisions between the centre-left Government and the conservative opposition, which had drawn support from Catholic movements. [Para 20]
  • State Under Review:

    San Marino

    San Marino
    Regional group
    WEOG
    Source Of Reference:

    Mexico

    Mexico
    Regional group
    GRULAC
    Political group
    OAS
    OEI
    ACS
    Issue:
    • Rights of same-sex desiring persons
    • Transgender persons' rights
    Type:
    Question
    Session:
    20th session, November 2014
    Status:
    Not Followed up with a Recommendation
    Contents:
    In light of the definition of what constitutes a "family" (present e.g. in Law no. 43), how are the rights of uni-parental and other non-conventional families protected?
  • State Under Review:

    San Marino

    San Marino
    Regional group
    WEOG
    Source Of Reference:

    Stakeholder Summary

    Issue:
    • Sexual abuse
    • Sexual exploitation / slavery
    Type:
    Review Documentation
    Session:
    34th Session, November 2019
    Status:
    Not Followed up with a Recommendation
    Contents:
    LC urged San Marino that have not yet done so to take the necessary legislative or other measures to ensure that child victims of sexual exploitation and sexual abuse affected by the refugee crisis may benefit from therapeutic assistance, notably emergency psychological care. [Para 82]
  • State Under Review:

    San Marino

    San Marino
    Regional group
    WEOG
    Source Of Reference:

    Austria

    Austria
    Regional group
    WEOG
    Political group
    EU
    Issue:
    • Training for state personnel on sexual rights issues
    • Domestic violence
    Type:
    Recommendation
    Session:
    7th session, February 2010
    Status:
    Accepted
    Contents:
    To provide specialized training to the police forces on how to deal with situations of domestic violence.
    Implementation
    National Report:
    Para 42) Decree no. 60/2012 provides for the mandatory training for all operators dealing with violence in various capacities (school, police forces, health and social services, lawyers and court). The Authority is responsible for annually promoting compulsory professional training courses in order to provide adequate tools and train personnel specialised in the fields of juridical, psychological and legal assistance to the victims of violence. The courses were launched in 2012 in collaboration with the Department of Training of the University of San Marino and a multiyear general plan will be soon developed for the training and refreshing of all operators, including police forces. During these courses, the contexts in which the actions of gender violence arise and the relevant reasons are analysed, in order to identify and prevent them, as well as the best practices shared at a national and international level in the field of assistance to victims.
  • State Under Review:

    San Marino

    San Marino
    Regional group
    WEOG
    Source Of Reference:

    National Report

    Issue:
    • Gender equality
    Type:
    Review Documentation
    Session:
    7th session, February 2010
    Status:
    N/A
    Contents:
    With regard to labour, Law No. 40 of 25 May 1981 prohibits any discrimination based on sex at all career levels. Today, the overall number of working women in San Marino accounts for about 42 percent of the total workforce. In the last 30 years, a widespread economic welfare and several provisions aimed at supporting women have enabled San Marino women to rapidly increase their participation in the social life of the Country. In addition, a relatively high number of women holds middle and middle-high ranking positions both in the public and the private sector. Different benefits (financial, tax benefits and real services) are envisaged for female proprietorships or companies owned by women or whose corporate capital is owned for 2/3 by women not exceeding 42 years of age (Law No. 134 of 24 November 1997). Finally, equal treatment in the field of work is also ensured by many provisions protecting maternity. [Para 35]
  • State Under Review:

    San Marino

    San Marino
    Regional group
    WEOG
    Source Of Reference:

    UN Compilation

    Issue:
    • HIV and AIDS
    Type:
    Review Documentation
    Session:
    7th session, February 2010
    Status:
    Neglected
    Contents:
    Adopt structured measures to combat HIV/AIDS. [Para 31; CESCR]
  • State Under Review:

    San Marino

    San Marino
    Regional group
    WEOG
    Source Of Reference:

    United Kingdom

    United Kingdom
    Regional group
    WEOG
    Political group
    EU
    Commonwealth
    Issue:
    • Rights of same-sex desiring persons
    • Transgender persons' rights
    Type:
    Recommendation
    Session:
    7th session, February 2010
    Status:
    Rejected
    Contents:
    To ensure that all members of society, including members of sexual minority groups, have access to equal rights and are afforded the same level of protection, through adequate legislation and awareness-raising and training programmes, especially with regard to integration.
    Explanation
    The legal order of the Republic of San Marino affirms and guarantees the principle of equality and the prohibition of any discrimination, as indicated in detail by the San Marino head of Delegation in her speech on the occasion of the seventh session of the UPR Working Group of the Human Rights Council. However, these Recommendations make reference to the category of "sexual minorities", which is not provided for by the San Marino legislation. Therefore, the Republic of San Marino is not in a position to accept these Recommendations.
    Implementation
    Stakeholder Summary:
    Para 8) CoE-ECRI noted that a law amending the Criminal Code with new provisions against discrimination based on ... sexual orientation grounds had been passed ...
  • State Under Review:

    San Marino

    San Marino
    Regional group
    WEOG
    Source Of Reference:

    Luxembourg

    Luxembourg
    Regional group
    WEOG
    Political group
    EU
    OIF
    Issue:
    • Discrimination based on sexual orientation
    • Discrimination based on gender identity
    Type:
    Recommendation
    Session:
    34th Session, November 2019
    Status:
    Accepted
    Contents:
    Include gender identity as a ground of discrimination in articles 90 and 179bis of the criminal code and promote public awareness of diversity and respect for sexual orientation and the gender identity of all persons, especially through human rights education and awareness raising campaigns.
  • State Under Review:

    San Marino

    San Marino
    Regional group
    WEOG
    Source Of Reference:

    Germany

    Germany
    Regional group
    WEOG
    Political group
    EU
    Issue:
    • International human rights instruments
    Type:
    Recommendation
    Session:
    20th session, November 2014
    Status:
    Accepted
    Contents:
    Ratify the OP-ICESCR and opt into the inquiry and inter-State mechanisms.
    Explanation
    San Marino administration has already carried out an examination of San Marino legislation for conformity with the OP-ICESCR and after assessing it as compliant, it has started the accession process.
    Implementation
    National Report:
    Para 15) In accordance with the recommendations accepted in the second UPR round: … (b) on 20 July 2015, San Marino acceded to the OP-ICESCR, done at New York on 10 December 2008, also accepting the competence of the CESCR under Articles 10 and 11 of the Covenant;

    UN Compilation:
    Para 2) The HR Committee welcomed the ratification of the OP-ICESCR …
  • State Under Review:

    San Marino

    San Marino
    Regional group
    WEOG
    Source Of Reference:

    UN Compilation

    Issue:
    • Gender equality
    Type:
    Review Documentation
    Session:
    34th Session, November 2019
    Status:
    Not Followed up with a Recommendation
    Contents:
    UNESCO encouraged San Marino to report to it in future on the implementation of the Recommendation on Science and Scientific Researchers, which had superseded the 1974 Recommendation in 2017, paying particular attention to the legal provisions and regulatory frameworks under which human rights were guaranteed for scientific researchers, to human rights obligations related to science, to the principle of nondiscrimination – including by actively encouraging women and girls to pursue scientific careers ... [Para 24]
  • State Under Review:

    San Marino

    San Marino
    Regional group
    WEOG
    Source Of Reference:

    Australia

    Australia
    Regional group
    WEOG
    Political group
    PIF
    Commonwealth
    Issue:
    • Rights of same-sex desiring persons
    • Transgender persons' rights
    Type:
    Recommendation
    Session:
    20th session, November 2014
    Status:
    Rejected
    Contents:
    Introduce appropriate administrative or legislative reforms to ensure equal protections for same-sex couples, including on matters of residency and inheritance.
    Explanation
    The San Marino legislation in force does not allow to accept this recommendation.
    Implementation
    National Report:
    Para 29) The fundamental principle of equality expressed in Art. 4 of the Declaration on the Citizens’ Rights is further applied in concrete terms in Law no. 66 of 28 April 2008 "Provisions on racial, ethnic, religious and sexual discrimination", which supplemented the provisions of the current Criminal Code. A new offence was introduced with Article 179 bis, which punishes anyone disseminating by any means ideas based on racial or ethnic superiority or hatred, or inciting someone to commit, or committing discriminatory acts on the grounds of race, ethnicity, nationality, religion or sexual orientation. This offence can be prosecuted ex officio. Article 179 bis was then amended with Law no. 57 of 6 May 2016 "Rules adjusting San Marino legal system to the provisions of the Council of Europe Convention on preventing and combating violence against women and domestic violence" by introducing the prohibition of discrimination based on gender identity.
    Para 28) … Moreover, Article 235 of the Criminal Code has been amended in relation to family maltreatment, also introducing the offence of domestic violence, and Article 179 bis of the Criminal Code has been supplemented with the prohibition to discriminate based on gender identity.
    Para 46) As already mentioned, Law no. 57/2016 introduced the prohibition of discrimination based on gender identity.
    Para 47) With Law no. 147 of 20 November 2018, San Marino has introduced a completely new and modern institution, mainly for the protection of same-sex couples, i.e. the "Law regulating civil registered partnerships", under which the legal system recognises equal dignity, rights and safeguards to civilly registered partners, both homosexual and heterosexual couples, compared to married ones. Citizens who decide to register their partnership civilly, in accordance with the aforementioned Law and its Regulation, acquire the same status as married couples in terms of residence and succession, cohabitation, mutual assistance, inheritance rights and other matters, whether the couple is of the same sex or of a different sex.
    Para 48) Sexual education programmes are carried out in schools at all levels where education is compulsory, accompanied by emotional education programmes: these two aspects are never separated from each other in view of an integrated and complex education. Moreover, in this regard, programmes are implemented concerning education on respect for others, non-violence, as well as inclusion and solidarity amongst peers. The “Curriculum of education to citizenship” has been introduced as part of the ongoing reform of San Marino school curricula. This curriculum expressly provides for knowledge of LGBT rights.

    UN Compilation:
    Para 9) While taking note of the existing legal provisions against discrimination, the Human Rights Committee was concerned that San Marino had not yet adopted comprehensive antidiscrimination legislation and that articles 90 and 179 bis of the Criminal Code relating to discrimination only referred to discrimination based on racial, ethnic, national, religious and sexual orientation grounds and not other grounds for discrimination, such as gender identity.
    Para 11) The OHCHR Regional Office for Europe noted with concern that same-sex couples did not have the right to adopt children, marry or obtain another form of legal recognition of their relationships in San Marino.

    Stakeholder Summary:
    Para 18) CHR of CoE observed that while discrimination, hate speech and hate crimes on the basis of sexual orientation had thus become criminal offences, no similar provision existed for gender identity or sex characteristics. The Commissioner also observed that there was no constitutional or other provision expressly providing for equality before the law irrespective of sexual orientation, gender identity or sex characteristics, nor specific civil or administrative law provisions explicitly prohibiting discrimination on these grounds in the field of employment, access to goods or services, or any other area.
  • State Under Review:

    San Marino

    San Marino
    Regional group
    WEOG
    Source Of Reference:

    Stakeholder Summary

    Issue:
    • Maternal health / morbidity / mortality
    Type:
    Review Documentation
    Session:
    34th Session, November 2019
    Status:
    Not Followed up with a Recommendation
    Contents:
    CGNK noted that ... figure for maternal mortality is missing. [Para 60]
  • State Under Review:

    San Marino

    San Marino
    Regional group
    WEOG
    Source Of Reference:

    National Report

    Issue:
    • Violence against women / gender-based violence
    • Domestic violence
    Type:
    Review Documentation
    Session:
    20th session, November 2014
    Status:
    N/A
    Contents:
    In addition, San Marino signed Protocol no. 16 to the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms of the Council of Europe and the Council of Europe Convention on Preventing and Combating Violence Against Women and Domestic Violence. The ratification procedure is ongoing for both instruments. [Para 24]
  • State Under Review:

    San Marino

    San Marino
    Regional group
    WEOG
    Source Of Reference:

    United Kingdom

    United Kingdom
    Regional group
    WEOG
    Political group
    EU
    Commonwealth
    Issue:
    • Violence against women / gender-based violence
    Type:
    Question
    Session:
    7th session, February 2010
    Status:
    Not Followed up with a Recommendation
    Contents:
    It inquired about steps taken to ensure legislation on violence against women covered all forms of gender-based violence.